Live

Loading latest market news…

InvestEdge360
Back to Knowledge Center
PMSComparisonBeginnerResearch Verified

Discretionary vs Non-Discretionary vs Advisory PMS: Which Is Right for You?

Compare the three PMS models by who decides, who executes, investor involvement, fee structures and risks before choosing a portfolio management service.

Published Thu Nov 12 2026Updated Tue Nov 17 202612 min read

Summary: Main distinctions among Discretionary, Non-discretionary and Advisory PMS are decision authority, execution responsibility and investor participation. This comparison outlines fees, reports, risks, minimum eligibility and questions to ask a provider in India.

Key Takeaways

  • In Discretionary PMS, investment decisions within the mandate are made by the provider. In a Non-Discretionary PMS, the investor makes the decisions.
  • In Advisory PMS, recommendations are made by the provider and the investor makes the decisions and maintains the relevant records.
  • PMS enables greater control over a portfolio. However, it does not remove the risks inherent in the markets.
  • PMS is more feasible for investors with an investment corpus of ₹50 lakh. There are, however, exceptions. Contracts that are Advisory in nature may have different thresholds.
  • Understand the actual costs, reports, authorization and exit terms of the provider.

🚀 Open your Demat & Trading account

  • Free Account opening charges
  • Free DP transaction charges ⭐
  • Free premium research & market updates
Talk to an AdvisorOpen Motilal Oswal Account

Last updated: 12 November 2026. If you are comparing discretionary vs. non-discretionary vs. advisory PMS in India, the main difference is in who decides what to invest in and who places the trade. In discretionary PMS, the portfolio manager decides within the limits of a pre-defined mandate. In non-discretionary PMS, the investor decides whether to accept proposed transactions, and the manager acts according to the investor’s instructions. In advisory PMS, the portfolio manager makes the recommendations, and the client is responsible for executing the recommendations.

No one of the three structures is necessarily better. The appropriate structure would be determined by the investor’s need for control and the time and effort he/she is able to devote to the exercise, costs, experience level, and the terms of the portfolio management services offered. This compares how they actually operate, and not based on what their labels mean.

Discretionary vs Non-Discretionary vs Advisory PMS: Key Differences

For an overview of how investment mandates and eligibility are discussed, see the Portfolio Management Services page. Before applying, find out from the PMS service provider the type of service (discretionary, non-discretionary or advisory PMS) that they actually offer, as making a PMS enquiry does not always mean that all the three services will be offered.

Comparison point

Discretionary PMS

Non-discretionary PMS

Advisory PMS

Who decides the investment?

Portfolio manager, within the agreed mandate

Investor, after considering the manager’s proposal

Investor, after receiving advice

Who executes?

Manager or its authorised execution arrangement

Manager as permitted under client directions

Investor through the investor’s own execution channel

How involved is the investor?

Lower day-to-day involvement; ongoing oversight remains important

Must review and communicate decisions promptly

Must evaluate advice, place orders and maintain records

Investment control

Delegated within stated restrictions

Client decides proposed transactions

Client retains both decision and execution responsibility

Timing considerations

Manager can act within the mandate without order-by-order approval

Approval delays may affect entry or exit prices

Investor availability and order handling affect implementation

Costs

Contractual management/performance and transaction charges as applicable

Provider-specific fees and transaction charges

Advice/service fees and independent trading-related costs as applicable

Portfolio reporting

Manager provides required account and performance reporting

Manager provides reporting for the managed arrangement

Scope of reporting and record-keeping depends on advisory agreement

Core risk

Manager decisions may not match expectations or outperform benchmarks

Investor delay, indecision or disagreement can affect results

Execution errors and failure to act can affect results

The table describes typical operating models. Exact trade authorities, reporting, fees, custody arrangements and responsibilities come from the provider’s signed agreement and disclosures; do not infer identical terms from the service label alone.

What Is Discretionary PMS?

A discretionary portfolio manager is free to make and execute transactions on behalf of the client without seeking approval for each order, as long as the decisions made are consistent with the client’s investment mandate and applicable laws and regulations. The client is involved in setting the objectives, investment approach, restrictions and other terms during the onboarding process. Delegating daily decisions is not the same as relinquishing the right to examine account statements and transacted orders, question costs and commissions and monitor the risks taken.

Let's say the client has agreed to an equity investment approach with pre-defined limits of risk. The portfolio manager is responsible for deciding when to initiate, rebalance and complete equity transactions within the agreed approach. The client, in such a case, needs to review the equity holdings, review and understand concentration risks, benchmark performance and agree to any changes to the mandate.

Practical consideration: This structure is acceptable to clients who are willing to evaluate the portfolio manager and review the consequences of giving the manager discretion over their assets, where returns may be negative. A professional mandate does not eliminate market or concentration risks.

What Is Non-Discretionary PMS?

In a non-discretionary PMS, a portfolio manager prepares investment proposals or recommendations, and the client makes the final investment decision. The manager implements the client’s investment decisions and manages the subsequent transactions according to the client’s instructions and the agreement. The client can accept, reject or amend a proposal made by the manager, within the limits permitted by the service provider.

This offers a meaningfully better approval step, however it does put the onus on the investor to respond within a limited time frame. An approved purchase instruction may become moot if the stock’s price changes. An instruction may also become impractical if there is low liquidity. Discuss what happens if an approval is not acted upon in the time allotted or if an instruction is not carried out.

Practical consideration: An investor who wants to review larger investment decisions may prefer this process, if he or she is able to respond in the time required.

What Is Advisory PMS?

PMS stands for Portfolio Management Service. PMS typically means full service where the portfolio is actively managed by the portfolio manager including order execution, back office services, etc. Advisory PMS means that the portfolio manager provides investment advice, but the client makes the decision to buy and sell securities and may outsource the remaining back office services. Advisory PMS allows the client to have greater control on how the advice is implemented. The exact scope of the advisory PMS needs to be reviewed in the advisory agreement.

Advisory PMS needs to be differentiated from other standalone investment advice services. The service provider, regulations, contract, asset threshold and fees need to be analyzed independently. Examine who gives the recommendations, who executes the trades, who keeps the records and who calculates or reports performance.

If a recommendation is not followed, actual results may vary substantially from modeled or illustrated performance. Investors choosing an advisory service need to be comfortable performing trades themselves, checking prices, reconciling positions and maintaining tax lot information.

One Stock Purchase: How Each PMS Model Would Handle It

Imagine a portfolio professional identifies a potential investment in the fictitious Company X and proposes buying shares worth ₹2 lakh for an otherwise eligible investor. This is a hypothetical workflow, not a recommendation to buy a security.

  1. Discretionary: The manager assesses whether the purchase fits the client mandate and, if so, arranges the order without requesting a separate trade-by-trade approval. The investor sees the transaction in subsequent records.

  2. Non-discretionary: The manager sends the proposed purchase and rationale. The investor approves or declines. The manager acts only on the instruction permitted by the agreement.

  3. Advisory: The professional sends a recommendation. The investor independently decides and, if proceeding, places the order through their chosen trading arrangement.

The same investment idea can therefore produce different transaction dates, prices and even different final portfolios. Higher control also creates more work for the investor; greater delegation creates more dependence on the manager’s process. Neither model changes the underlying share-market risk.

PMS Fees, Reporting and Responsibilities Compared

There is no uniform ranking of the three arrangements. Management fees can be fixed or variable. Other costs like brokerage, custody or other fees are disclosed. Advisory arrangements can vary in scope and pricing. In comparing costs, see what has been signed and not what is disclosed in marketing collateral. One Stock Purchase: How Each PMS Model Would Handle It

Let’s say a portfolio professional spots an attractive opportunity in Company X and suggests purchase of shares worth 2 lakhs of this company for an otherwise eligible investor. The following is a hypothetical situation.

  1. Discretionary: The manager takes the decision to buy shares and communicates the same to the broker. If the purchase price is within the client’s mandate, then the order is executed. The investor will find the purchase in his next statement.

  2. Non-discretionary: The manager gives the idea and rationale for the purchase. The investor approves or disapproves the purchase. The manager acts only on the purchase limit order permitted by the agreement.

  3. Advisory: The professional gives a buy recommendation. The investor decides to buy and, depending on the chosen broker, executes the trade.

The same investment idea can therefore produce different transaction dates, prices and even different final portfolios. Higher control also creates more work for the investor; greater delegation creates more dependence on the manager’s process. Neither model changes the underlying share-market risk.

PMS Fees, Reporting and Responsibilities Compared

There is currently no trusted single-fee ranking for the three models. Providers can charge various kinds of fees. Choose the advisory arrangement that is most suitable, then explore the terms. Remember to evaluate the total cost of the arrangement, not just the advertised fee percentage.

Question to ask

Why it matters

How are fees calculated and when are they charged?

A percentage of portfolio value differs from a fixed annual fee or a performance-linked arrangement.

What execution and custody costs apply?

These expenses can affect the amount actually retained after transactions.

How are performance figures reported?

Understand the benchmark, calculation method, valuation date and treatment of cash flows and fees.

Who maintains transaction and tax information?

The work may differ between managed and advice-only service models.

What happens when an approval is delayed?

Non-discretionary decisions may be missed, resubmitted or re-priced under agreed procedures.

For managed PMS models, client reporting is a regulatory requirement. Reports are to be issued at the latest, three months apart. The reports should detail the portfolio, including transactions, expenses and receipts. In advice-only arrangements, assess the precise reporting commitments, and don’t make assumptions about administrative processes. For more information about funding, onboarding and reading reports, refer to the PMS onboarding-to-reporting guide.

Which PMS Type May Suit Your Involvement Level?

This is less about identifying the 'best' type and more about figuring out the investor's actual working preferences:

  • Busy professional: For this type of professional, discretionary PMS is worth exploring if they are making too many day-to-day decisions but the investor needs to oversee the manager's performance, costs and risks.

  • Experienced investor seeking approval rights: Non-discretionary PMS can be an option if the investor is not available to make the decisions but another person (in this case the manager) is available to provide instructions.

  • Investor comfortable placing trades: If the investor is not only comfortable making trades but also prefers to receive advice, then an advisory PMS can be explored.

  • Investor comparing products: Before choosing any model, evaluate investment objectives, concentration, tax implications, portfolio liquidity and alternative structures. A separate PMS versus mutual funds comparison can help with that wider choice.

These examples are to explain broad concepts, not to assist in making an investment decision. There are a lot of variations among products offering similar services. This includes, but is not limited to, fees, strategies, structures and the services offered.

PMS Minimum Investment and SEBI Rules in November 2026

As per the SEBI Portfolio Managers Regulations, 2020, the general minimum requirement for managing client funds or securities in a PMS portfolio is Rs. 50 lakhs, subject to certain exceptions, including the relevant accredited investor provisions. A PMS provider can fix a higher minimum requirement. One should not assume that a similar arrangement and minimum requirement exist for every advice-only service. The service provider in question should be asked to clarify their position and the legal basis for the arrangement.

The 2020 rules remain in effect as of 12 November 2026. SEBI published replacement Portfolio Managers Regulations in October 2026, to come into effect from 1 April 2027. The announced future start date should not be construed to mean that the rules are currently in effect.

Prior to signing, check the actual manager’s registration record on SEBI’s official intermediary listings, read the disclosure document and confirm which service is being offered. The operator of a website discussing PMS is not, by itself, authorized to manage client portfolios. For broader definitions and investor obligations, read the introduction to Portfolio Management Services.

Checklist: What to Ask Before Choosing a PMS Provider

  1. Authority: Who makes buy/sell decisions? Can I impose exclusions or concentration limits?

  2. Execution: Who executes the trades and after whose approval?

  3. Documentation: What disclosure document, client agreement, KYC and risk-profile records must I review?

  4. Minimum and funding: Does ₹50 lakh refer to this structure? Is there an exception? Is there a higher product minimum or restriction on which securities can be transferred?

  5. Fees: What are the illustrations of all the charges, performance fees (if any), and transaction costs and exit costs?

  6. Reporting: Who reconciles the actual holdings against the recommended holdings?

  7. Exit and complaints: What are the processes for withdrawal, settlement, termination and grievance?

If you have any clarifications about the service or documents offered, you can send a PMS eligibility enquiry. You can also contact us for information about your next steps. An enquiry will not be considered an investment instruction or approval to open an account. All contractual arrangements and terms must be agreed upon with the service provider.

The Bottom Line: Choose a Decision Process You Can Sustain

In a discretionary PMS, the decision making in regards to trades is delegated within an agreed upon mandate, while in a non-discretionary PMS the investor retains the buy/sell decisions. An advisory PMS is where decisions are made, but the execution is delegated to the investor. Choose the option which you understand, can supervise and is affordable. Before selecting a PMS provider, consider and evaluate the full investment strategy. Consider how you will be able to supervise the downside.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the main difference between discretionary and non-discretionary PMS?+

With discretionary PMS, the manager makes investment decisions within the agreed mandate. With non-discretionary PMS, the client retains the final buy/sell decision and the manager acts under the client’s directions.

Who places trades in advisory PMS?+

Typically the client decides whether to follow advice and independently executes through the client’s trading arrangement. The exact advice and reporting services are defined in the contract.

Does non-discretionary PMS require my approval for every transaction?+

The investor retains decision-making authority. The approval mechanism, standing instructions and permitted execution process must be checked in the client agreement; do not assume a universal workflow.

Is discretionary PMS better for a busy investor?+

It can reduce day-to-day approval work, but it does not remove the need to review fees, strategy, concentration and reports. Whether it fits depends on objectives and comfort with delegation.

Is the minimum PMS investment ₹50 lakh for every type?+

₹50 lakh is the general regulatory threshold for accepting funds or securities under managed PMS, with specified exceptions. Advisory-only service structures can differ; verify eligibility and terms with the actual provider.

Is advisory PMS the same as using an investment adviser?+

Not necessarily. Advisory PMS is a service offered under a portfolio manager’s regulatory framework and client agreement. Standalone investment advice can involve a different regulatory status and scope.

Can I lose money in any of the three PMS models?+

Yes. Market movements, security selection, costs, liquidity and execution decisions can lead to losses in each service structure.

Which PMS reports and fees should I check?+

Ask for the full fee schedule, transaction costs, portfolio statements, performance and benchmark methodology, reporting frequency, complaint channels and withdrawal conditions.

Disclaimer

This article is for general education and does not provide individual investment, tax or legal advice. InvestEdge360 is operated by Vijayvargiya Financial Services, an Authorized Business Partner of Motilal Oswal Financial Services Ltd.; it is not the official Motilal Oswal website. Portfolio management, if available, is subject to the actual provider’s regulatory status, disclosures and client agreement. Investments can fall in value.

Research Team

InvestEdge360 Research

Content Research Desk

Insights from InvestEdge360's research desk — written to help investors learn with clarity and invest with discipline.

Need Help Comparing PMS Service Models?

Explore PMS eligibility, decision-making arrangements, documented charges and onboarding information through InvestEdge360. Actual services are subject to the relevant portfolio manager’s terms.

Explore PMS Options

Was this article helpful?

Explore More